Happy 75th Anniversary to Batman!

Started by Silver Nemesis, Sun, 30 Mar 2014, 16:51

Previous topic - Next topic
I've always been curious how the Bruce Wayne show would've turned out.

Smallville works for me because there's plenty of comic book precedent for Superboy. Ultimately, Smallville became a hodge podge of influences. Primarily Silver Age but plenty of Post-Crisis, Bronze Age and Golden Age thrown in as well.

But Batman doesn't really have that type of flexibility. At least, not as far as I know. The idea of an unmasked Bruce Wayne squaring off with all or most of Batman's rogue's gallery... I'm not sure how that would've worked.

I think things worked out for the best with this series.

That series probably would've been like Gotham, only with the production values of Birds of Prey and a lot more teen angst. Smallville worked because it was effectively a Superboy show, but there isn't really a comparable Batboy-era of Bruce's life to provide the basis for a teenage Batman show.

The closest thing we have to that now would be Gotham High, which is a hideous stain on the history of Batman comics. No one wants to see that story adapted for screen.

A Bruce Wayne show could work if it worked as a story largely about the time he traveled abroad. You could do it as a eastern martial arts show set largely at the dojo and surrounding country or maybe as a wandering man show ala Kung Fu where he walks among the towns and villages of Asia/Europe helping people as a nomadic samurai all before he went back to Gotham.


Dan Jurgens & Dick Giordano Batman Art from 1983.





Dan commented on X that he still had the training wheels on at this stage in his career, but even still, I think the talent was evident.
"Imagination is a quality given a man to compensate him for what he is not, and a sense of humour was provided to console him for what he is."

Obvious talent. But not so much of Jurgens's own voice. That Batman seems heavily influenced by Marshall Rogers and Neil Adams.

Which is no criticism. If anything, I probably would've preferred it if he had stuck with that model. Because the occasions he drew Batman in the Nineties are... not great.


There's something to that.

When thinking of Jurgens' Batman, this is pretty much the first thing that comes to mind. Probably because it was around this time, that I started paying attention to the creatives, and not just visuals/stories.



I don't think Jurgens' Batman is necessarily bad, but will agree that his style never really popped as it did for Superman (same goes for John Byrne honestly). Which, I would say, made Dan as THE defining artist for Superman in the 1990's.

Though I will say, ever since Zero Hour, I do think Dan does a pretty good job with Batgirl.


"Imagination is a quality given a man to compensate him for what he is not, and a sense of humour was provided to console him for what he is."