Quote from: PJ on Thu, 10 Apr 2008, 20:37
I'm sorry, but this is getting silly. I am UK editor of BoF and calling Jett "Anti-Burton" is just downright incorrect. He loves B89, it's just that he hates Batman Returns. That's his preference. BoF does currently have a Nolan slant, of course it does. BB happens to be Jett's preferred film and the Nolan films are current. We all have our bias, just look at this site for example. That's not a slight on Raleagh's site. I love it, but it's clear that his preference is the two Burton movies (mine too pretty much).
Of course it's his personal preference. Jett seems to minimally vouch for Batman as a character. Supposedly, he is still a Batman fan. Yet remarkably, when I look at batman-on-film.com (though rarely as it may be for me), with the Batman mythology having taken a back seat, and the Nolan franchise clearly having such precedence, Jett's loyalties and the extent thereof are put into full question.
It's beyond a passive Nolan inclination. On top of that, it's a guy who takes his opinion very seriously, and undeniably DOES have a voice in the fan community, a LOUD one just as you stated.
Thus, we'll play the game. We'll take his essays seriously at least on the objective level that he influences newcomers to the mythology. That means answering his less professional work (if you can call ANY of his work professional... what I see from Jett's style is amateurish at best). He opens himself up for scrutiny by the public with his criticisms of Burton. When a prominent voice in the fan community writes misguided ignorance, it is the order of responsible Batman fans to POINT OUT the ignorance, and make it as wide-spread and readable as he has MADE HIS OPINION.
QuoteTo say that BoF is completely biased towards Nolan is just not true. Look around a bit more, you'll see lots of stuff by other writers, Jett included, that covers the whole gamut of Batman on film. I have been inactive due to a heavy workload this past year, but I'm hoping to commit more time to BoF, hopefully that might balance things out in the eyes of some.
We look forward to it.
QuoteDon't be so hard on the guy, he receives hundreds and I do mean hundreds of hate mail a day. You may have valid criticisms of some of the things he says, but it will be lost in the deluge of BS he has to deal with on a daily basis.
Gotham Knight was presented with definite ways to bypass the piles of bullsh*t. If he proceeds, the situation will grow quite interesting, I daresay.
QuoteIf you want to express your points, I invite you to the BoF boards. There is currently a great debate going on in the Burton/Schumacher section. Why not show your support for your favourite films there. Either that or write an opinion piece. If it's good Jett will publish it. Just look at how many Op-ed pieces he's already put up.
Thanks for the invitation. Nonetheless... do you really believe any comments vaguely critical of Jett will be tolerated? I think not. If we transfer to the BOF forums our valid points against the BR review, for instance, I don't expect those posts to last long; the deletion of naysayers' words and a clean sweep under the rug is a habit I sense is ubiquitous there.
QuoteAnd a very positive one on BR from Gregg Bray
http://www.batman-on-film.com/opinion_bray_returns.html
The above is evidence that the other movies have a presence over there, Jett's voice is the loudest because the site is his, but don't think for a second that his is the only opinion that counts.
I'll take a peek at them later. Thank you for sharing the links.